Place a medium saucepan on your stove at the lowest setting. Pour in the apple cider and throw in 1 cinnamon stick. Allow to heat as you make the other components
Gather the ingredients for the candy cap that will go over your glass of choice. We used 4 oz cups to get 6 servings
Mix the sugar, corn syrup, and water in a separate, medium saucepan over medium heat with a wooden spoon
Bring the mixture to a boil and insert a candy thermometer. Have the food dye and silicon mold at the ready because the mixture will harden quickly when it's done cooking. Once the mixture reaches 300℉/200℃, remove from heat. Stir the mixture together
Add the red food dye a few drops at a time but be careful as the mixture may bubble up and splash. Mix until you get the desired red color (this was between ¼ tsp and ½ tsp for us)
Quickly pour up to just under half of the depth of the silicone molds (just enough to cover the bottom). Remember, we want the candy circles to be thin enough to break with a spoon. You should have just enough to fill the 6 circles. You may need to slightly jiggle the mold to get the candy mixture to spread but try not to lift up or move the mold from your surface
While the candy hardens in the molds, you can set up your 6 cups. Spoon 1 TBSP of salted caramel sauce into the bottom of each cup and drizzle around if you want more along the sides
Distribute the apple cider into each cup. You can also add 1.5 oz of spiced rum if you want to make this a cocktail. You can stir now or wait until the candy falls in
Gently tap the top of the candy circles with your fingers to check if it's hardened enough. If so, gently remove them from the silicon mold and place them on top of each cup
Take a spoon and crack the candy cap into the cup! Stir the mixture with the candy in the cup and add a cinnamon stick for garnish or use as a straw if you want to add more fun! We recommend allowing the apple cider to melt the candy for a minute or two before sipping. Enjoy!